By Arlen Grossman/ The Big Picture Report
President Obama’s choice for CIA Director, counterterrorism adviser John Brennan, will face a Senate confirmation hearing Thursday. Undoubtedly, he will have to answer questions about a 16-page leaked Justice Department memo obtained by NBC News that outlines the legal theories the Obama administration is using to justify killing American citizens abroad.
The confidential 2011 memo states the administration view that the president or another “informed, high-level official” can order the extrajudicial killing of an American citizen overseas without violating the Constitution, acts of Congress or international law. The Obama administration apparently chooses to ignore the part in the U.S. Constitution that states no American can “be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”
Among the senators Brennan will face will be Ron Wyden (D-OR), a member of the Senate intelligence committee, who sent a letter three weeks ago to the nominee asking for an outline of the legal and practical rules and rationale for the U.S. government’s targeted killing of American citizens suspected of working with al-Qaida. He wrote in that letter (which Brennan has not responded to):
For the executive branch to claim that intelligence agencies have the authority to knowingly kill American citizens but refuse to provide Congress with any and all legal opinions that explain the executive branch’s understanding of this authority represents an alarming and indefensible assertion of executive prerogative.”
The Oregon senator asked some very pointed questions that Mr. Brennan should be required to answer, but will likely try to wriggle out from. Among the questions posed to the nominee in that letter:
1. “How much evidence does the President need to determine that a particular American can be lawfully killed?”
2. “Does the President have to provide individual Americans with the opportunity to surrender before killing them?”
3. “Are there any geographic limitations on the intelligence community’s authority to use lethal force against Americans? Do any intelligence agencies have the authority to carry out lethal operations inside the United States?
Eleven senators (eight Democrats and three Republicans) wrote a letter to President Obama Monday demanding the administration hand over its legal justifications for drone strikes on U.S. citizens. Despite expected tough questioning, Brennan is expected to be confirmed as the next CIA director.
A complete copy of Senator Wyden’s Questions (from his January 14 letter):
I wouldn’t say we should eliminate the drone program, but yes, I’d like see the responses too, and probably have Supreme Court weigh in on those.
I don’t trust the Supreme Court, or any other branch of our government. It seems “national security” always trumps the Constitution.
I don’t 100% trust them either, but at least this Supreme Court would not be too sympathetic to administration’s arguments. Besides, what other options we have – have Raytheon or Lockheed Martin decide who represents an legitimate target for a drone attack?
Conservatives love the idea of bombing other countries with drones and no accountability. I’ve got a better idea: stop killing people in other countries and stop trying to police the world.
I can agree with that.
Sen. Wyden’s questions are excellent ones. I hope he gets answers and shares them with the rest of us.